Out In Force   Out In Force
Sexual Orientation and the Military

Edited by
Gregory M. Herek, Ph.D.
Jared B. Jobe, Ph.D. &
Ralph M. Carney, Ph.D.

(The University of Chicago Press, 1996)

 
Overview  

In 1993, the country engaged in a heated national debate about whether the United States military should lift its long-standing ban on service by gay men and lesbians. The compromise eventually reached by President Clinton and the Congress – popularly labeled, "Don't ask, don't tell, don't pursue" – was challenged in the courts, but the U.S. Supreme Court has consistently declined to consider the constitutionality of the policy. Nevertheless, the controversy surrounding this issue is likely to shape national policies and attitudes concerning sexual orientation well into the new millennium.
 

Table of Contents

 

Extended Summary

  Both sides in the debate have repeatedly based their arguments on assumptions and predictions about the consequences of integrating gay people into the military. What would be the effect on unit cohesion and morale? How could heterosexuals' privacy concerns be resolved? Would heterosexual personnel follow orders from a gay superior? Are heterosexuals' hostilities toward gay people so entrenched that they cannot be softened or eradicated? Would gay people face isolation or violence?

Out In Force presents a comprehensive review of social science data relevant to these and related questions. Its 15 chapters by some of the nation's leading social science scholars on sexual orientation and the military offer reasoned and dispassionate discussions of what we know about military organizations, human sexuality, and attitudes toward individuals and groups. The contributors are experts on military psychology, lesbian and gay psychology, organizational psychology, social psychology, and clinical psychology. They include five authors who wrote sections of the RAND Corporation's landmark 1993 report to the Secretary of Defense on the current military policy.

Table of Contents
 
Preface
 
Part One: An Orientation to the Issue

Chapter 1. Social Science, Sexual Orientation, and Military Personnel Policy
Gregory M. Herek

Chapter 2. Sexual Orientation and Proscribed Sexual Behaviors
Janet Lever & David E. Kanouse

Chapter 3. Sexual Orientation and the Military: Some Legal Considerations
Peter D. Jacobson
 

Part Two: Relevant Experience from Other Domains  

Chapter 4. Integration of Women in the Military: Parallels to the Progress of Homosexuals?
Patricia J. Thomas & Marie D. Thomas

Chapter 5. Applying Lessons Learned From Minority Integration in the Military
Michael R. Kauth & Dan Landis

Chapter 6. The Experiences of Foreign Militaries
Paul A. Gade, David R. Segal, & Edgar M. Johnson

Chapter 7. Lessons Learned From The Experience of Domestic Police and Fire Departments
Paul Koegel
 

Part Three: Cohesion, Privacy, and Attitudes  

Chapter 8. Sexual Orientation and Military Cohesion: A Critical Review of the Evidence
Robert MacCoun

Chapter 9. The Deconstruction of Stereotypes: Homosexuals and Military Policy
Theodore R. Sarbin

Chapter 10. Why Tell If You're Not Asked? Self-Disclosure, Intergroup Contact, and Heterosexuals' Attitudes Toward Lesbians and Gay Men
Gregory M. Herek

Chapter 11. Sexual Modesty, the Etiquette of Disregard, and the Question of Gays and Lesbians in the Military
Lois Shawver
 

Part Four: Implementation  

Chapter 12. Issues of Confidentiality: Therapists, Chaplains and Health Care Providers
Jeffrey E. Barnett & Timothy B. Jeffrey

Chapter 13. Implementing Policy Changes in Large Organizations: The Case of Gays and Lesbians in the Military
Gail L. Zellman

Chapter 14. The President, the Congress, and the Pentagon: Obstacles to Implementing the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Policy
Lawrence J. Korb

Chapter 15. Conclusion